{ "version": 2, "status": "approved canonical identity", "rosterPolicy": "roster-policy-2026-10-10-v9", "selectedGenera": 1314, "identities": { "307772": { "orig_no": "307772", "taxon_no": "307772", "record_type": "txn", "flags": "B", "taxon_name": "Shuuvuia", "taxon_attr": "Chiappe et al. 1998", "accepted_no": "307772", "accepted_rank": "genus", "accepted_name": "Shuuvuia", "parent_no": "66045", "reference_no": "13618", "is_extant": "extinct", "n_occs": 0, "primary_reference": "L. M. Chiappe, M. A. Norell, and J. M. Clark. 1998. The skull of a relative of the stem-group bird Mononykus. Nature 392:275-278", "senpar_name": "Mononykini", "senpar_rank": 25, "immpar_name": "Mononykini", "parent_txn": { "orig_no": "66045", "taxon_no": "290135", "taxon_rank": 25, "taxon_name": "Mononykini", "taxon_size": 2, "extant_size": 0 }, "kingdom_no": "67091", "kingdom": "Animalia", "kingdom_txn": { "orig_no": "67091", "taxon_no": "325038", "taxon_rank": 23, "taxon_name": "Animalia", "taxon_size": 306225, "extant_size": 48166 }, "phylum_no": "33815", "phylum": "Chordata", "phylum_txn": { "orig_no": "33815", "taxon_no": "33815", "taxon_rank": 20, "taxon_name": "Chordata", "taxon_size": 75002, "extant_size": 15279 }, "class_no": "36322", "class": "Reptilia", "class_txn": { "orig_no": "36322", "taxon_no": "36322", "taxon_rank": 17, "taxon_name": "Reptilia", "taxon_size": 21484, "extant_size": 5675 }, "family_no": "64116", "family": "Alvarezsauridae", "family_txn": { "orig_no": "64116", "taxon_no": "64116", "taxon_rank": 9, "taxon_name": "Alvarezsauridae", "taxon_size": 39, "extant_size": 0 }, "children": [], "subgenus_list": [], "species_list": [], "genus": "Shuuvuia", "genus_no": "307772" }, "66043": { "orig_no": "66043", "taxon_no": "66043", "record_type": "txn", "flags": "B", "taxon_name": "Shuvuuia", "taxon_attr": "Chiappe et al. 1998", "accepted_no": "66043", "accepted_rank": "genus", "accepted_name": "Shuvuuia", "parent_no": "68181", "reference_no": "13618", "is_extant": "extinct", "n_occs": 3, "firstapp_max_ma": 83.6, "firstapp_min_ma": 72.2, "lastapp_max_ma": 83.6, "lastapp_min_ma": 72.2, "early_interval": "Campanian", "primary_reference": "L. M. Chiappe, M. A. Norell, and J. M. Clark. 1998. The skull of a relative of the stem-group bird Mononykus. Nature 392:275-278", "senpar_name": "Parvicursorinae", "senpar_rank": 8, "immpar_name": "Parvicursorinae", "parent_txn": { "orig_no": "68181", "taxon_no": "162355", "taxon_rank": 8, "taxon_name": "Parvicursorinae", "taxon_size": 26, "extant_size": 0 }, "kingdom_no": "67091", "kingdom": "Animalia", "kingdom_txn": { "orig_no": "67091", "taxon_no": "325038", "taxon_rank": 23, "taxon_name": "Animalia", "taxon_size": 306225, "extant_size": 48166 }, "phylum_no": "33815", "phylum": "Chordata", "phylum_txn": { "orig_no": "33815", "taxon_no": "33815", "taxon_rank": 20, "taxon_name": "Chordata", "taxon_size": 75002, "extant_size": 15279 }, "class_no": "36322", "class": "Reptilia", "class_txn": { "orig_no": "36322", "taxon_no": "36322", "taxon_rank": 17, "taxon_name": "Reptilia", "taxon_size": 21484, "extant_size": 5675 }, "family_no": "64116", "family": "Alvarezsauridae", "family_txn": { "orig_no": "64116", "taxon_no": "64116", "taxon_rank": 9, "taxon_name": "Alvarezsauridae", "taxon_size": 39, "extant_size": 0 }, "children": [ { "orig_no": "66044", "taxon_no": "66044", "taxon_rank": 3, "taxon_name": "Shuvuuia deserti", "taxon_size": 1, "extant_size": 0, "firstapp_max_ma": "83.60000" } ], "subgenus_list": [], "species_list": [ { "orig_no": "66044", "taxon_no": "66044", "taxon_rank": 3, "taxon_name": "Shuvuuia deserti", "taxon_size": 1, "extant_size": 0, "firstapp_max_ma": "83.60000" } ], "genus": "Shuvuuia", "genus_no": "66043" } }, "selectedOpinions": { "307772": { "opinion_no": "508053", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "class", "taxon_rank": "genus", "taxon_name": "Shuuvuia", "orig_no": "307772", "child_spelling_no": "307772", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Mononykini", "parent_no": "66045", "spelling_reason": "original spelling", "author": "Agnolin et al.", "pubyr": "2012", "ref_author": "Agnolin et al.", "ref_pubyr": "2012", "reference_no": "42494", "primary_reference": "F. L. Agnolin, J. E. Powell, and F. E. Novas, M. Kundrát. 2012. New alvarezsaurid (Dinosauria, Theropoda) from uppermost Cretaceous of north-western Patagonia with associated eggs. Cretaceous Research 35(1):33-56" }, "66043": { "opinion_no": "939591", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "class", "taxon_rank": "genus", "taxon_name": "Shuvuuia", "orig_no": "66043", "child_spelling_no": "66043", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Parvicursorinae", "parent_no": "68181", "spelling_reason": "correction", "author": "Kubo et al.", "pubyr": "2023", "ref_author": "Kubo et al.", "ref_pubyr": "2023", "reference_no": "86504", "primary_reference": "K. Kubo, Y. Kobayashi, and T. Chinzorig, K. Tsogtbaatar. 2023. A new alvarezsaurid dinosaur (Theropoda, Alvarezsauria) from the Upper Cretaceous Baruungoyot Formation of Mongolia provides insights for bird-like sleeping behavior in nonavian dinosaurs. PLoS ONE 18(11):e0293801:1-38" } }, "opinionsByIdentity": { "307772": [ { "opinion_no": "508053", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "class", "taxon_rank": "genus", "taxon_name": "Shuuvuia", "orig_no": "307772", "child_spelling_no": "307772", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Mononykini", "parent_no": "66045", "spelling_reason": "original spelling", "author": "Agnolin et al.", "pubyr": "2012", "ref_author": "Agnolin et al.", "ref_pubyr": "2012", "reference_no": "42494", "primary_reference": "F. L. Agnolin, J. E. Powell, and F. E. Novas, M. Kundrát. 2012. New alvarezsaurid (Dinosauria, Theropoda) from uppermost Cretaceous of north-western Patagonia with associated eggs. Cretaceous Research 35(1):33-56" }, { "opinion_no": "140021", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "unsel", "taxon_rank": "genus", "taxon_name": "Shuuvuia", "orig_no": "307772", "child_spelling_no": "307772", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Alvarezsauridae", "parent_no": "64116", "spelling_reason": "original spelling", "author": "Norell and Makovicky", "pubyr": "1999", "ref_author": "Norell and Makovicky", "ref_pubyr": "1999", "reference_no": "18147", "primary_reference": "M. A. Norell and P. J. Makovicky. 1999. Important features of the dromaeosaur skeleton II: information from newly collected specimens of Velociraptor mongoliensis. American Museum Novitates 3282:1-45" }, { "opinion_no": "95457", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "unsel", "taxon_rank": "genus", "taxon_name": "Shuuvuia", "orig_no": "307772", "child_spelling_no": "307772", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Mononykinae", "parent_no": "66045", "parent_spelling_no": "66045", "spelling_reason": "original spelling", "author": "Chiappe et al.", "pubyr": "1998", "ref_author": "Chiappe et al.", "ref_pubyr": "1998", "reference_no": "13618", "primary_reference": "L. M. Chiappe, M. A. Norell, and J. M. Clark. 1998. The skull of a relative of the stem-group bird Mononykus. Nature 392:275-278" } ], "66043": [ { "opinion_no": "939591", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "class", "taxon_rank": "genus", "taxon_name": "Shuvuuia", "orig_no": "66043", "child_spelling_no": "66043", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Parvicursorinae", "parent_no": "68181", "spelling_reason": "correction", "author": "Kubo et al.", "pubyr": "2023", "ref_author": "Kubo et al.", "ref_pubyr": "2023", "reference_no": "86504", "primary_reference": "K. Kubo, Y. Kobayashi, and T. Chinzorig, K. Tsogtbaatar. 2023. A new alvarezsaurid dinosaur (Theropoda, Alvarezsauria) from the Upper Cretaceous Baruungoyot Formation of Mongolia provides insights for bird-like sleeping behavior in nonavian dinosaurs. PLoS ONE 18(11):e0293801:1-38" }, { "opinion_no": "923556", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "unsel", "taxon_rank": "genus", "taxon_name": "Shuvuuia", "orig_no": "66043", "child_spelling_no": "66043", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Parvicursorinae", "parent_no": "68181", "spelling_reason": "correction", "author": "Averianov and Lopatin", "pubyr": "2021", "ref_author": "Averianov and Lopatin", "ref_pubyr": "2021", "reference_no": "84741", "primary_reference": "A. O. Averianov and A. V. Lopatin. 2021. A re-appraisal of Parvicursor remotus from the Late Cretaceous of Mongolia: implications for the phylogeny and taxonomy of alvarezsaurid theropod dinosaurs. Journal of Systematic Palaeontology 19(16):1097-1128" }, { "opinion_no": "503614", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "unsel", "taxon_rank": "genus", "taxon_name": "Shuvuuia", "orig_no": "66043", "child_spelling_no": "66043", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Maniraptoriformes", "parent_no": "57429", "spelling_reason": "correction", "author": "Hendrickx and Mateus", "pubyr": "2014", "ref_author": "Hendrickx and Mateus", "ref_pubyr": "2014", "reference_no": "49990", "primary_reference": "C. Hendrickx and O. Mateus. 2014. Abelisauridae (Dinosauria: Theropoda) from the Late Jurassic of Portugal and dentition-based phylogeny as a contribution for the indentification of isolated theropod teeth. Zootaxa 3759(1):1-74" }, { "opinion_no": "557383", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "unsel", "taxon_rank": "genus", "taxon_name": "Shuvuuia", "orig_no": "66043", "child_spelling_no": "66043", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Alvarezsauridae", "parent_no": "64116", "spelling_reason": "correction", "author": "Delcourt and Grillo", "pubyr": "2014", "ref_author": "Delcourt and Grillo", "ref_pubyr": "2014", "reference_no": "54109", "primary_reference": "R. Delcourt and O. N. Grillo. 2014. On maniraptoran material (Dinosauria: Theropoda) from Vale do Rio do Peixe Formation, Bauru Group, Brazil. Revista Brasileira de Paleontologia 17(3):307-316" }, { "opinion_no": "868998", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "unsel", "taxon_rank": "genus", "taxon_name": "Shuvuuia", "orig_no": "66043", "child_spelling_no": "66043", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Parvicursorinae", "parent_no": "68181", "spelling_reason": "correction", "author": "Novas et al.", "pubyr": "2013", "ref_author": "Novas et al.", "ref_pubyr": "2013", "reference_no": "79677", "primary_reference": "F. E. Novas, F. L. Agnolín, and M. D. Ezcurra, J. Porfiri, J. I. Canale. 2013. Evolution of the carnivorous dinosaurs during the Cretaceous: The evidence from Patagonia. Cretaceous Research 45:174-215" }, { "opinion_no": "322145", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "unsel", "taxon_rank": "genus", "taxon_name": "Shuvuuia", "orig_no": "66043", "child_spelling_no": "66043", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Alvarezsauridae", "parent_no": "64116", "spelling_reason": "correction", "author": "Nesbitt et al.", "pubyr": "2011", "ref_author": "Nesbitt et al.", "ref_pubyr": "2011", "reference_no": "35185", "primary_reference": "S. J. Nesbitt, J. A. Clarke, and A. H. Turner, M. A. Norell. 2011. A small alvarezsaurid from the Eastern Gobi Desert offers insight into evolutionary patterns in the Alvarezsauroidea. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 31(1):144-153" }, { "opinion_no": "495943", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "unsel", "taxon_rank": "genus", "taxon_name": "Shuvuuia", "orig_no": "66043", "child_spelling_no": "66043", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Alvarezsauridae", "parent_no": "64116", "spelling_reason": "correction", "author": "Gianechini et al.", "pubyr": "2011", "ref_author": "Gianechini et al.", "ref_pubyr": "2011", "reference_no": "49276", "primary_reference": "F. A. Gianechini, P. J. Makovicky, and S. Apesteguía. 2011. The teeth of the unenlagiine theropod Buitreraptor from the Cretaceous of Patagonia, Argentina, and the unusual dentition of the Gondwanan dromaeosaurids. Acta Palaeontologica Polonica 56(2):279-290" }, { "opinion_no": "295871", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "unsel", "taxon_rank": "genus", "taxon_name": "Shuvuuia", "orig_no": "66043", "child_spelling_no": "66043", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Parvicursorinae", "parent_no": "68181", "spelling_reason": "correction", "author": "Choiniere et al.", "pubyr": "2010", "ref_author": "Choiniere et al.", "ref_pubyr": "2010", "reference_no": "31855", "primary_reference": "J. N. Choiniere, X. Xu, and J. M. Clark, C. A. Forster, Y. Guo, F. Han. 2010. A basal alvarezsauroid theropod from the early Late Jurassic of Xinjiang, China. Science 327(5965):571-574" }, { "opinion_no": "300896", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "unsel", "taxon_rank": "genus", "taxon_name": "Shuvuuia", "orig_no": "66043", "child_spelling_no": "66043", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Parvicursorinae", "parent_no": "68181", "spelling_reason": "correction", "author": "Xu et al.", "pubyr": "2010", "ref_author": "Xu et al.", "ref_pubyr": "2010", "reference_no": "32350", "primary_reference": "X. Xu, D.-Y. Wang, and C. Sullivan, D. W. E. Hone, F.-L. Han, R.-H. Yan, F.-M. Du. 2010. A basal parvicursorine (Theropoda: Alvarezsauridae) from the Upper Cretaceous of China. Zootaxa 2413:1-19" }, { "opinion_no": "317058", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "unsel", "taxon_rank": "genus", "taxon_name": "Shuvuuia", "orig_no": "66043", "child_spelling_no": "66043", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Alvarezsauridae", "parent_no": "64116", "spelling_reason": "correction", "author": "Longrich et al.", "pubyr": "2010", "ref_author": "Longrich et al.", "ref_pubyr": "2010", "reference_no": "34573", "primary_reference": "N. R. Longrich, P. J. Currie, and Z.-M. Dong. 2010. A new oviraptorid (Dinosauria: Theropoda) from the Upper Cretaceous of Bayan Mandahu, Inner Mongolia. Palaeontology 53(5):945-960" }, { "opinion_no": "255179", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "unsel", "taxon_rank": "genus", "taxon_name": "Shuvuuia", "orig_no": "66043", "child_spelling_no": "66043", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Mononykinae", "parent_no": "66045", "parent_spelling_no": "66045", "spelling_reason": "correction", "author": "Longrich and Currie", "pubyr": "2009", "ref_author": "Longrich and Currie", "ref_pubyr": "2009", "reference_no": "29124", "primary_reference": "N. R. Longrich and P. J. Currie. 2009. Albertonykus borealis, a new alvarezsaur (Dinosauria: Theropoda) from the Early Maastrichtian of Alberta, Canada: implications for the systematics and ecology of the Alvarezsauridae. Cretaceous Research 30(1):239-252" }, { "opinion_no": "303771", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "unsel", "taxon_rank": "genus", "taxon_name": "Shuvuuia", "orig_no": "66043", "child_spelling_no": "66043", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Alvarezsauridae", "parent_no": "64116", "spelling_reason": "correction", "author": "Salgado et al.", "pubyr": "2009", "ref_author": "Salgado et al.", "ref_pubyr": "2009", "reference_no": "32505", "primary_reference": "L. Salgado, R. A. Coria, and A. B. Arcucci, L. M. Chiappe. 2009. Restos de Alvarezsauridae (Theropoda, Coelurosauria) en la Formación Allen (Campaniano-Maastrictiano), en Salitral Ojo de Agua, Provincia de Río Negro, Argentina. Andean Geology 36(1):67-80" }, { "opinion_no": "311990", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "unsel", "taxon_rank": "genus", "taxon_name": "Shuvuuia", "orig_no": "66043", "child_spelling_no": "66043", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Alvarezsauridae", "parent_no": "64116", "spelling_reason": "correction", "author": "Turner et al.", "pubyr": "2009", "ref_author": "Turner et al.", "ref_pubyr": "2009", "reference_no": "33957", "primary_reference": "A. H. Turner, S. J. Nesbitt, and M. A. Norell. 2009. A large alvarezsaurid from the Late Cretaceous of Mongolia. American Museum Novitates 3648:1-14" }, { "opinion_no": "264287", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "unsel", "taxon_rank": "genus", "taxon_name": "Shuvuuia", "orig_no": "66043", "child_spelling_no": "66043", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Parvicursoridae", "parent_no": "68181", "parent_spelling_no": "68181", "spelling_reason": "correction", "author": "Alifanov and Barsbold", "pubyr": "2009", "ref_author": "Alifanov and Barsbold", "ref_pubyr": "2009", "reference_no": "29706", "primary_reference": "V. R. Alifanov and R. Barsbold. 2009. Ceratonykus oculatus gen. et sp. nov., a new dinosaur (? Theropoda, Alvarezsauria) from the Late Cretaceous of Mongolia. Paleontological Journal 43(1):94-106" }, { "opinion_no": "243379", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "unsel", "taxon_rank": "genus", "taxon_name": "Shuvuuia", "orig_no": "66043", "child_spelling_no": "66043", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Mononykinae", "parent_no": "66045", "parent_spelling_no": "66045", "spelling_reason": "correction", "author": "Martinelli and Vera", "pubyr": "2007", "ref_author": "Martinelli and Vera", "ref_pubyr": "2007", "reference_no": "28254", "primary_reference": "A. G. Martinelli and E. I. Vera. 2007. Achillesaurus manzzonei, a new alvarezsaurid theropod (Dinosauria) from the Late Cretaceous Bajo de la Carpa Formation, Río Negro Province, Argentina. Zootaxa 1582:1-17" }, { "opinion_no": "103966", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "unsel", "taxon_rank": "genus", "taxon_name": "Shuvuuia", "orig_no": "66043", "child_spelling_no": "66043", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Alvarezsauridae", "parent_no": "64116", "spelling_reason": "correction", "author": "Padian", "pubyr": "2004", "ref_author": "Padian", "ref_pubyr": "2004", "reference_no": "15102", "primary_reference": "K. Padian. 2004. Basal Avialae. In D. B. Weishampel, P. Dodson, and H. Osmólska (eds.), The Dinosauria (second edition). University of California Press, Berkeley" }, { "opinion_no": "255589", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "unsel", "taxon_rank": "genus", "taxon_name": "Shuvuuia", "orig_no": "66043", "child_spelling_no": "66043", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Mononykinae", "parent_no": "66045", "parent_spelling_no": "66045", "spelling_reason": "correction", "author": "Chiappe et al.", "pubyr": "2002", "ref_author": "Chiappe et al.", "ref_pubyr": "2002", "reference_no": "29148", "primary_reference": "L. M. Chiappe, M. A. Norell, and J. M. Clark. 2002. The Cretaceous, short-armed Alvarezsauridae: Mononykus and its kin. In L. M. Chiappe and L. M. Witmer (eds.), Mesozoic Birds: Above the Heads of Dinosaurs. University of California Press, Berkeley" }, { "opinion_no": "255751", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "unsel", "taxon_rank": "genus", "taxon_name": "Shuvuuia", "orig_no": "66043", "child_spelling_no": "66043", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Alvarezsauridae", "parent_no": "64116", "spelling_reason": "correction", "author": "Chiappe", "pubyr": "2002", "ref_author": "Chiappe", "ref_pubyr": "2002", "reference_no": "29153", "primary_reference": "L. M. Chiappe. 2002. Basal bird phylogeny: problems and solutions. Mesozoic Birds: Above the Heads of Dinosaurs. University of California Press, Berkeley" }, { "opinion_no": "95458", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "unsel", "taxon_rank": "genus", "taxon_name": "Shuvuuia", "orig_no": "66043", "child_spelling_no": "66043", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Mononykinae", "parent_no": "66045", "parent_spelling_no": "66045", "spelling_reason": "correction", "author": "Suzuki et al.", "pubyr": "2002", "ref_author": "Suzuki et al.", "ref_pubyr": "2002", "reference_no": "13617", "primary_reference": "S. Suzuki, L. M. Chiappe, and G. J. Dyke, M. Watabe, R. Barsbold, K. Tsogtbaatar. 2002. A new specimen of Shuvuuia deserti Chiappe et al., 1998 from the Mongolian Late Cretaceous with a discussion of the relationships of alvarezsaurids to other theropod dinosaurs. Contributions in Science, Natural History Museum of Los Angeles County 494:1-18" }, { "opinion_no": "939563", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "class", "taxon_rank": "species", "taxon_name": "Shuvuuia deserti", "orig_no": "66044", "child_spelling_no": "66044", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Shuvuuia", "parent_no": "66043", "spelling_reason": "original spelling", "author": "Kubo et al.", "pubyr": "2023", "ref_author": "Kubo et al.", "ref_pubyr": "2023", "reference_no": "86504", "primary_reference": "K. Kubo, Y. Kobayashi, and T. Chinzorig, K. Tsogtbaatar. 2023. A new alvarezsaurid dinosaur (Theropoda, Alvarezsauria) from the Upper Cretaceous Baruungoyot Formation of Mongolia provides insights for bird-like sleeping behavior in nonavian dinosaurs. PLoS ONE 18(11):e0293801:1-38" }, { "opinion_no": "931722", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "unsel", "taxon_rank": "species", "taxon_name": "Shuvuuia deserti", "orig_no": "66044", "child_spelling_no": "66044", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Shuvuuia", "parent_no": "66043", "spelling_reason": "original spelling", "author": "Averianov et al.", "pubyr": "2023", "ref_author": "Averianov et al.", "ref_pubyr": "2023", "reference_no": "85565", "primary_reference": "A. O. Averianov, P. P. Skutschas, and A. V. Lopatin. 2023. Ontogeny and miniaturization of Alvarezsauridae (Dinosauria, Theropoda). Biological Communications 68(2):65-73" }, { "opinion_no": "896151", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "unsel", "taxon_rank": "species", "taxon_name": "Shuvuuia deserti", "orig_no": "66044", "child_spelling_no": "66044", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Shuvuuia", "parent_no": "66043", "spelling_reason": "original spelling", "author": "Czepiński", "pubyr": "2020", "ref_author": "Czepiński", "ref_pubyr": "2020", "reference_no": "82280", "primary_reference": "Ł. Czepiński. 2020. New protoceratopsid specimens improve the age correlation of the Upper Cretaceous Gobi Desert strata. Acta Palaeontologica Polonica 65(3):481-497" }, { "opinion_no": "935200", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "unsel", "taxon_rank": "species", "taxon_name": "Shuvuuia deserti", "orig_no": "66044", "child_spelling_no": "66044", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Shuvuuia", "parent_no": "66043", "spelling_reason": "original spelling", "author": "Norell et al.", "pubyr": "2018", "ref_author": "Norell et al.", "ref_pubyr": "2018", "reference_no": "86065", "primary_reference": "M. A. Norell, A. M. Balanoff, and D. E. Barta, G. M. Erickson. 2018. A second specimen of Citipati osmolskae associated with a nest of eggs from Ukhaa Tolgod, Omnogov Aimag, Mongolia. American Museum Novitates 3899:1-44" }, { "opinion_no": "557384", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "unsel", "taxon_rank": "species", "taxon_name": "Shuvuuia deserti", "orig_no": "66044", "child_spelling_no": "66044", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Shuvuuia", "parent_no": "66043", "spelling_reason": "original spelling", "author": "Delcourt and Grillo", "pubyr": "2014", "ref_author": "Delcourt and Grillo", "ref_pubyr": "2014", "reference_no": "54109", "primary_reference": "R. Delcourt and O. N. Grillo. 2014. On maniraptoran material (Dinosauria: Theropoda) from Vale do Rio do Peixe Formation, Bauru Group, Brazil. Revista Brasileira de Paleontologia 17(3):307-316" }, { "opinion_no": "876691", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "unsel", "taxon_rank": "species", "taxon_name": "Shuvuuia deserti", "orig_no": "66044", "child_spelling_no": "66044", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Shuvuuia", "parent_no": "66043", "spelling_reason": "original spelling", "author": "Xu et al.", "pubyr": "2013", "ref_author": "Xu et al.", "ref_pubyr": "2013", "reference_no": "80822", "primary_reference": "X. Xu, P. Upchurch, and Q. Ma, M. Pittman, J. Choiniere, C. Sullivan, D. W. E. Hone, Q. Tan, L. Tan, D. Xiao, F. Han. 2013. Osteology of the alvarezsauroid Linhenykus monodactylus from the Upper Cretaceous Wulansuhai Formation of Inner Mongolia, China, and comments on alvarezsauroid biogeography. Acta Palaeontologica Polonica 58(1):25-46" }, { "opinion_no": "880246", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "unsel", "taxon_rank": "species", "taxon_name": "Shuvuuia deserti", "orig_no": "66044", "child_spelling_no": "66044", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Shuvuuia", "parent_no": "66043", "spelling_reason": "original spelling", "author": "Turner et al.", "pubyr": "2011", "ref_author": "Turner et al.", "ref_pubyr": "2011", "reference_no": "41123", "primary_reference": "A. H. Turner, D. Pol, and M. A. Norell. 2011. Anatomy of Mahakala omnogovae (Theropoda: Dromaeosauridae), Tögrögiin Shiree, Mongolia. American Museum Novitates 3722:1-66" }, { "opinion_no": "495966", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "unsel", "taxon_rank": "species", "taxon_name": "Shuvuuia deserti", "orig_no": "66044", "child_spelling_no": "66044", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Shuvuuia", "parent_no": "66043", "spelling_reason": "original spelling", "author": "Gianechini et al.", "pubyr": "2011", "ref_author": "Gianechini et al.", "ref_pubyr": "2011", "reference_no": "49276", "primary_reference": "F. A. Gianechini, P. J. Makovicky, and S. Apesteguía. 2011. The teeth of the unenlagiine theropod Buitreraptor from the Cretaceous of Patagonia, Argentina, and the unusual dentition of the Gondwanan dromaeosaurids. Acta Palaeontologica Polonica 56(2):279-290" }, { "opinion_no": "295874", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "unsel", "taxon_rank": "species", "taxon_name": "Shuvuuia deserti", "orig_no": "66044", "child_spelling_no": "66044", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Shuvuuia", "parent_no": "66043", "spelling_reason": "original spelling", "author": "Choiniere et al.", "pubyr": "2010", "ref_author": "Choiniere et al.", "ref_pubyr": "2010", "reference_no": "31855", "primary_reference": "J. N. Choiniere, X. Xu, and J. M. Clark, C. A. Forster, Y. Guo, F. Han. 2010. A basal alvarezsauroid theropod from the early Late Jurassic of Xinjiang, China. Science 327(5965):571-574" }, { "opinion_no": "300907", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "unsel", "taxon_rank": "species", "taxon_name": "Shuvuuia deserti", "orig_no": "66044", "child_spelling_no": "66044", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Shuvuuia", "parent_no": "66043", "spelling_reason": "original spelling", "author": "Xu et al.", "pubyr": "2010", "ref_author": "Xu et al.", "ref_pubyr": "2010", "reference_no": "32350", "primary_reference": "X. Xu, D.-Y. Wang, and C. Sullivan, D. W. E. Hone, F.-L. Han, R.-H. Yan, F.-M. Du. 2010. A basal parvicursorine (Theropoda: Alvarezsauridae) from the Upper Cretaceous of China. Zootaxa 2413:1-19" }, { "opinion_no": "317062", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "unsel", "taxon_rank": "species", "taxon_name": "Shuvuuia deserti", "orig_no": "66044", "child_spelling_no": "66044", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Shuvuuia", "parent_no": "66043", "spelling_reason": "original spelling", "author": "Longrich et al.", "pubyr": "2010", "ref_author": "Longrich et al.", "ref_pubyr": "2010", "reference_no": "34573", "primary_reference": "N. R. Longrich, P. J. Currie, and Z.-M. Dong. 2010. A new oviraptorid (Dinosauria: Theropoda) from the Upper Cretaceous of Bayan Mandahu, Inner Mongolia. Palaeontology 53(5):945-960" }, { "opinion_no": "279439", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "unsel", "taxon_rank": "species", "taxon_name": "Shuvuuia deserti", "orig_no": "66044", "child_name": "Shuuvia deserti", "child_spelling_no": "96512", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Shuvuuia", "parent_no": "66043", "spelling_reason": "misspelling", "author": "Bever and Norell", "pubyr": "2009", "ref_author": "Bever and Norell", "ref_pubyr": "2009", "reference_no": "30727", "primary_reference": "G. S. Bever and M. A. Norell. 2009. The perinate skull of Byronosaurus (Troodontidae) with observations on the cranial ontogeny of paravian theropods. American Museum Novitates 3657:1-51" }, { "opinion_no": "255185", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "unsel", "taxon_rank": "species", "taxon_name": "Shuvuuia deserti", "orig_no": "66044", "child_spelling_no": "66044", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Shuvuuia", "parent_no": "66043", "spelling_reason": "original spelling", "author": "Longrich and Currie", "pubyr": "2009", "ref_author": "Longrich and Currie", "ref_pubyr": "2009", "reference_no": "29124", "primary_reference": "N. R. Longrich and P. J. Currie. 2009. Albertonykus borealis, a new alvarezsaur (Dinosauria: Theropoda) from the Early Maastrichtian of Alberta, Canada: implications for the systematics and ecology of the Alvarezsauridae. Cretaceous Research 30(1):239-252" }, { "opinion_no": "311986", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "unsel", "taxon_rank": "species", "taxon_name": "Shuvuuia deserti", "orig_no": "66044", "child_spelling_no": "66044", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Shuvuuia", "parent_no": "66043", "spelling_reason": "original spelling", "author": "Turner et al.", "pubyr": "2009", "ref_author": "Turner et al.", "ref_pubyr": "2009", "reference_no": "33957", "primary_reference": "A. H. Turner, S. J. Nesbitt, and M. A. Norell. 2009. A large alvarezsaurid from the Late Cretaceous of Mongolia. American Museum Novitates 3648:1-14" }, { "opinion_no": "264286", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "unsel", "taxon_rank": "species", "taxon_name": "Shuvuuia deserti", "orig_no": "66044", "child_spelling_no": "66044", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Shuvuuia", "parent_no": "66043", "spelling_reason": "original spelling", "author": "Alifanov and Barsbold", "pubyr": "2009", "ref_author": "Alifanov and Barsbold", "ref_pubyr": "2009", "reference_no": "29706", "primary_reference": "V. R. Alifanov and R. Barsbold. 2009. Ceratonykus oculatus gen. et sp. nov., a new dinosaur (? Theropoda, Alvarezsauria) from the Late Cretaceous of Mongolia. Paleontological Journal 43(1):94-106" }, { "opinion_no": "243380", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "unsel", "taxon_rank": "species", "taxon_name": "Shuvuuia deserti", "orig_no": "66044", "child_spelling_no": "66044", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Shuvuuia", "parent_no": "66043", "spelling_reason": "original spelling", "author": "Martinelli and Vera", "pubyr": "2007", "ref_author": "Martinelli and Vera", "ref_pubyr": "2007", "reference_no": "28254", "primary_reference": "A. G. Martinelli and E. I. Vera. 2007. Achillesaurus manzzonei, a new alvarezsaurid theropod (Dinosauria) from the Late Cretaceous Bajo de la Carpa Formation, Río Negro Province, Argentina. Zootaxa 1582:1-17" }, { "opinion_no": "167247", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "unsel", "taxon_rank": "species", "taxon_name": "Shuvuuia deserti", "orig_no": "66044", "child_name": "Shuuvia deserti", "child_spelling_no": "96512", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Shuvuuia", "parent_no": "66043", "spelling_reason": "misspelling", "author": "Turner et al.", "pubyr": "2007", "ref_author": "Turner et al.", "ref_pubyr": "2007", "reference_no": "23562", "primary_reference": "A. H. Turner, S. H. Hwang, and M. A. Norell. 2007. A small derived theropod from Öösh, Early Cretaceous, Baykhangor Mongolia. American Museum Novitates 3557:1-27" }, { "opinion_no": "103967", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "unsel", "taxon_rank": "species", "taxon_name": "Shuvuuia deserti", "orig_no": "66044", "child_spelling_no": "66044", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Shuvuuia", "parent_no": "66043", "spelling_reason": "original spelling", "author": "Padian", "pubyr": "2004", "ref_author": "Padian", "ref_pubyr": "2004", "reference_no": "15102", "primary_reference": "K. Padian. 2004. Basal Avialae. In D. B. Weishampel, P. Dodson, and H. Osmólska (eds.), The Dinosauria (second edition). University of California Press, Berkeley" }, { "opinion_no": "95456", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "unsel", "taxon_rank": "species", "taxon_name": "Shuvuuia deserti", "orig_no": "66044", "child_spelling_no": "66044", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Shuvuuia", "parent_no": "66043", "spelling_reason": "original spelling", "author": "Suzuki et al.", "pubyr": "2002", "ref_author": "Suzuki et al.", "ref_pubyr": "2002", "reference_no": "13617", "primary_reference": "S. Suzuki, L. M. Chiappe, and G. J. Dyke, M. Watabe, R. Barsbold, K. Tsogtbaatar. 2002. A new specimen of Shuvuuia deserti Chiappe et al., 1998 from the Mongolian Late Cretaceous with a discussion of the relationships of alvarezsaurids to other theropod dinosaurs. Contributions in Science, Natural History Museum of Los Angeles County 494:1-18" }, { "opinion_no": "255590", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "unsel", "taxon_rank": "species", "taxon_name": "Shuvuuia deserti", "orig_no": "66044", "child_spelling_no": "66044", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Shuvuuia", "parent_no": "66043", "spelling_reason": "original spelling", "author": "Chiappe et al.", "pubyr": "2002", "ref_author": "Chiappe et al.", "ref_pubyr": "2002", "reference_no": "29148", "primary_reference": "L. M. Chiappe, M. A. Norell, and J. M. Clark. 2002. The Cretaceous, short-armed Alvarezsauridae: Mononykus and its kin. In L. M. Chiappe and L. M. Witmer (eds.), Mesozoic Birds: Above the Heads of Dinosaurs. University of California Press, Berkeley" }, { "opinion_no": "255710", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "unsel", "taxon_rank": "species", "taxon_name": "Shuvuuia deserti", "orig_no": "66044", "child_spelling_no": "66044", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Shuvuuia", "parent_no": "66043", "spelling_reason": "original spelling", "author": "Chiappe", "pubyr": "2002", "ref_author": "Chiappe", "ref_pubyr": "2002", "reference_no": "29153", "primary_reference": "L. M. Chiappe. 2002. Basal bird phylogeny: problems and solutions. Mesozoic Birds: Above the Heads of Dinosaurs. University of California Press, Berkeley" }, { "opinion_no": "140013", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "unsel", "taxon_rank": "species", "taxon_name": "Shuvuuia deserti", "orig_no": "66044", "child_spelling_no": "66044", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Shuvuuia", "parent_no": "66043", "spelling_reason": "original spelling", "author": "Norell and Makovicky", "pubyr": "1999", "ref_author": "Norell and Makovicky", "ref_pubyr": "1999", "reference_no": "18147", "primary_reference": "M. A. Norell and P. J. Makovicky. 1999. Important features of the dromaeosaur skeleton II: information from newly collected specimens of Velociraptor mongoliensis. American Museum Novitates 3282:1-45" }, { "opinion_no": "95455", "record_type": "opn", "opinion_type": "unsel", "taxon_rank": "species", "taxon_name": "Shuvuuia deserti", "orig_no": "66044", "child_spelling_no": "66044", "status": "belongs to", "parent_name": "Shuvuuia", "parent_no": "66043", "spelling_reason": "original spelling", "author": "Chiappe et al.", "pubyr": "1998", "ref_author": "Chiappe et al.", "ref_pubyr": "1998", "reference_no": "13618", "primary_reference": "L. M. Chiappe, M. A. Norell, and J. M. Clark. 1998. The skull of a relative of the stem-group bird Mononykus. Nature 392:275-278" } ] }, "manifest": { "source": "PBDB data service 1.2", "requests": { "307772-identity": { "url": "https://paleobiodb.org/data1.2/taxa/single.json?id=307772&show=attr,app,ref,nav,classext&vocab=pbdb", "retrieved": "2026-10-10T10:06:31.922328+00:00", "file": "raw/307772-identity.json.gz", "sha256": "3646a0fb9088fe24d9bda1749c13b50d148ae6fcb201821597aa6208aafe498e", "records": 1 }, "307772-opinions": { "url": "https://paleobiodb.org/data1.2/taxa/opinions.json?base_id=307772&show=ref,refattr&vocab=pbdb", "retrieved": "2026-10-10T10:06:37.722573+00:00", "file": "raw/307772-opinions.json.gz", "sha256": "f2e92347f28a165013c82d7a7a370d134adc5c3099eaa47959037c6c9653833d", "records": 3 }, "66043-identity": { "url": "https://paleobiodb.org/data1.2/taxa/single.json?id=66043&show=attr,app,ref,nav,classext&vocab=pbdb", "retrieved": "2026-10-10T10:06:43.629710+00:00", "file": "raw/66043-identity.json.gz", "sha256": "fdd0d8c57803f689e0504121041fd1b1c424f752d61fe1d070951b75a94b6313", "records": 1 }, "66043-opinions": { "url": "https://paleobiodb.org/data1.2/taxa/opinions.json?base_id=66043&show=ref,refattr&vocab=pbdb", "retrieved": "2026-10-10T10:06:49.592791+00:00", "file": "raw/66043-opinions.json.gz", "sha256": "af462c56589f8b5de019c966bcb7c26d3c64b3280b077304bacba5bcc32141f3", "records": 42 } } }, "conclusion": "The same cited original description, corrected-spelling opinions and primary literature support treating these spellings as one genus. PBDB still self-accepts both identities, so the game applies an explicitly approved identity exception.", "treatment": { "canonicalId": "66043", "canonicalName": "Shuvuuia", "heldRecordId": "307772", "heldRecordName": "Shuuvuia", "independentAnswer": false, "occurrenceTransfer": false, "ancestryTransfer": false, "implementation": "applied to expanded-roster review" }, "comparisons": [ { "target": "Ceratonykus", "targetId": "145604", "anchor": "Baruungoyot Formation · MN", "beforeMin": 5, "beforeMax": 6, "afterMin": 4, "afterMax": 5, "comparison": { "knownMatches": [ "Ceratonykus", "Jaculinykus", "Khulsanurus", "Ondogurvel", "Parvicursor" ], "qualifiedOnlyMatches": [], "unknownMetadata": [], "provisionalNonMatches": [ "Albinykus", "Dzharaonyx", "Linhenykus", "Mononykus", "Shuvuuia", "Xixianykus" ], "retainedCount": 5, "occurrenceIdsByGenus": { "Ceratonykus": [ "809197" ], "Jaculinykus": [ "1639584" ], "Khulsanurus": [ "1604958" ], "Ondogurvel": [ "1593675" ], "Parvicursor": [ "283992" ] }, "literatureIdsByGenus": { "Ceratonykus": [ "asian-sauropod-1" ], "Jaculinykus": [ "asian-sauropod-1" ], "Khulsanurus": [ "asian-sauropod-1" ], "Ondogurvel": [ "asian-sauropod-1" ], "Parvicursor": [ "asian-sauropod-1" ] } }, "states": [ { "probeId": "177464", "probe": "Albinykus", "remainingCount": 5, "remainingIds": [ "145604", "455665", "461663", "479065", "68182" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 }, { "probeId": "473892", "probe": "Dzharaonyx", "remainingCount": 5, "remainingIds": [ "145604", "455665", "461663", "479065", "68182" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 }, { "probeId": "479065", "probe": "Jaculinykus", "remainingCount": 4, "remainingIds": [ "145604", "455665", "461663", "68182" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 }, { "probeId": "461663", "probe": "Khulsanurus", "remainingCount": 4, "remainingIds": [ "145604", "455665", "479065", "68182" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 }, { "probeId": "175493", "probe": "Linhenykus", "remainingCount": 5, "remainingIds": [ "145604", "455665", "461663", "479065", "68182" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 }, { "probeId": "53210", "probe": "Mononykus", "remainingCount": 5, "remainingIds": [ "145604", "455665", "461663", "479065", "68182" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 }, { "probeId": "455665", "probe": "Ondogurvel", "remainingCount": 4, "remainingIds": [ "145604", "461663", "479065", "68182" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 }, { "probeId": "68182", "probe": "Parvicursor", "remainingCount": 4, "remainingIds": [ "145604", "455665", "461663", "479065" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 }, { "probeId": "66043", "probe": "Shuvuuia", "remainingCount": 5, "remainingIds": [ "145604", "455665", "461663", "479065", "68182" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 }, { "probeId": "165127", "probe": "Xixianykus", "remainingCount": 5, "remainingIds": [ "145604", "455665", "461663", "479065", "68182" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 } ] }, { "target": "Jaculinykus", "targetId": "479065", "anchor": "Baruungoyot Formation · MN", "beforeMin": 5, "beforeMax": 6, "afterMin": 4, "afterMax": 5, "comparison": { "knownMatches": [ "Ceratonykus", "Jaculinykus", "Khulsanurus", "Ondogurvel", "Parvicursor" ], "qualifiedOnlyMatches": [], "unknownMetadata": [], "provisionalNonMatches": [ "Albinykus", "Dzharaonyx", "Linhenykus", "Mononykus", "Shuvuuia", "Xixianykus" ], "retainedCount": 5, "occurrenceIdsByGenus": { "Ceratonykus": [ "809197" ], "Jaculinykus": [ "1639584" ], "Khulsanurus": [ "1604958" ], "Ondogurvel": [ "1593675" ], "Parvicursor": [ "283992" ] }, "literatureIdsByGenus": { "Ceratonykus": [ "asian-sauropod-1" ], "Jaculinykus": [ "asian-sauropod-1" ], "Khulsanurus": [ "asian-sauropod-1" ], "Ondogurvel": [ "asian-sauropod-1" ], "Parvicursor": [ "asian-sauropod-1" ] } }, "states": [ { "probeId": "177464", "probe": "Albinykus", "remainingCount": 5, "remainingIds": [ "145604", "455665", "461663", "479065", "68182" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 }, { "probeId": "145604", "probe": "Ceratonykus", "remainingCount": 4, "remainingIds": [ "455665", "461663", "479065", "68182" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 }, { "probeId": "473892", "probe": "Dzharaonyx", "remainingCount": 5, "remainingIds": [ "145604", "455665", "461663", "479065", "68182" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 }, { "probeId": "461663", "probe": "Khulsanurus", "remainingCount": 4, "remainingIds": [ "145604", "455665", "479065", "68182" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 }, { "probeId": "175493", "probe": "Linhenykus", "remainingCount": 5, "remainingIds": [ "145604", "455665", "461663", "479065", "68182" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 }, { "probeId": "53210", "probe": "Mononykus", "remainingCount": 5, "remainingIds": [ "145604", "455665", "461663", "479065", "68182" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 }, { "probeId": "455665", "probe": "Ondogurvel", "remainingCount": 4, "remainingIds": [ "145604", "461663", "479065", "68182" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 }, { "probeId": "68182", "probe": "Parvicursor", "remainingCount": 4, "remainingIds": [ "145604", "455665", "461663", "479065" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 }, { "probeId": "66043", "probe": "Shuvuuia", "remainingCount": 5, "remainingIds": [ "145604", "455665", "461663", "479065", "68182" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 }, { "probeId": "165127", "probe": "Xixianykus", "remainingCount": 5, "remainingIds": [ "145604", "455665", "461663", "479065", "68182" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 } ] }, { "target": "Khulsanurus", "targetId": "461663", "anchor": "Baruungoyot Formation · MN", "beforeMin": 5, "beforeMax": 6, "afterMin": 4, "afterMax": 5, "comparison": { "knownMatches": [ "Ceratonykus", "Jaculinykus", "Khulsanurus", "Ondogurvel", "Parvicursor" ], "qualifiedOnlyMatches": [], "unknownMetadata": [], "provisionalNonMatches": [ "Albinykus", "Dzharaonyx", "Linhenykus", "Mononykus", "Shuvuuia", "Xixianykus" ], "retainedCount": 5, "occurrenceIdsByGenus": { "Ceratonykus": [ "809197" ], "Jaculinykus": [ "1639584" ], "Khulsanurus": [ "1604958" ], "Ondogurvel": [ "1593675" ], "Parvicursor": [ "283992" ] }, "literatureIdsByGenus": { "Ceratonykus": [ "asian-sauropod-1" ], "Jaculinykus": [ "asian-sauropod-1" ], "Khulsanurus": [ "asian-sauropod-1" ], "Ondogurvel": [ "asian-sauropod-1" ], "Parvicursor": [ "asian-sauropod-1" ] } }, "states": [ { "probeId": "177464", "probe": "Albinykus", "remainingCount": 5, "remainingIds": [ "145604", "455665", "461663", "479065", "68182" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 }, { "probeId": "145604", "probe": "Ceratonykus", "remainingCount": 4, "remainingIds": [ "455665", "461663", "479065", "68182" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 }, { "probeId": "473892", "probe": "Dzharaonyx", "remainingCount": 5, "remainingIds": [ "145604", "455665", "461663", "479065", "68182" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 }, { "probeId": "479065", "probe": "Jaculinykus", "remainingCount": 4, "remainingIds": [ "145604", "455665", "461663", "68182" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 }, { "probeId": "175493", "probe": "Linhenykus", "remainingCount": 5, "remainingIds": [ "145604", "455665", "461663", "479065", "68182" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 }, { "probeId": "53210", "probe": "Mononykus", "remainingCount": 5, "remainingIds": [ "145604", "455665", "461663", "479065", "68182" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 }, { "probeId": "455665", "probe": "Ondogurvel", "remainingCount": 4, "remainingIds": [ "145604", "461663", "479065", "68182" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 }, { "probeId": "68182", "probe": "Parvicursor", "remainingCount": 4, "remainingIds": [ "145604", "455665", "461663", "479065" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 }, { "probeId": "66043", "probe": "Shuvuuia", "remainingCount": 5, "remainingIds": [ "145604", "455665", "461663", "479065", "68182" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 }, { "probeId": "165127", "probe": "Xixianykus", "remainingCount": 5, "remainingIds": [ "145604", "455665", "461663", "479065", "68182" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 } ] }, { "target": "Ondogurvel", "targetId": "455665", "anchor": "Baruungoyot Formation · MN", "beforeMin": 5, "beforeMax": 6, "afterMin": 4, "afterMax": 5, "comparison": { "knownMatches": [ "Ceratonykus", "Jaculinykus", "Khulsanurus", "Ondogurvel", "Parvicursor" ], "qualifiedOnlyMatches": [], "unknownMetadata": [], "provisionalNonMatches": [ "Albinykus", "Dzharaonyx", "Linhenykus", "Mononykus", "Shuvuuia", "Xixianykus" ], "retainedCount": 5, "occurrenceIdsByGenus": { "Ceratonykus": [ "809197" ], "Jaculinykus": [ "1639584" ], "Khulsanurus": [ "1604958" ], "Ondogurvel": [ "1593675" ], "Parvicursor": [ "283992" ] }, "literatureIdsByGenus": { "Ceratonykus": [ "asian-sauropod-1" ], "Jaculinykus": [ "asian-sauropod-1" ], "Khulsanurus": [ "asian-sauropod-1" ], "Ondogurvel": [ "asian-sauropod-1" ], "Parvicursor": [ "asian-sauropod-1" ] } }, "states": [ { "probeId": "177464", "probe": "Albinykus", "remainingCount": 5, "remainingIds": [ "145604", "455665", "461663", "479065", "68182" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 }, { "probeId": "145604", "probe": "Ceratonykus", "remainingCount": 4, "remainingIds": [ "455665", "461663", "479065", "68182" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 }, { "probeId": "473892", "probe": "Dzharaonyx", "remainingCount": 5, "remainingIds": [ "145604", "455665", "461663", "479065", "68182" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 }, { "probeId": "479065", "probe": "Jaculinykus", "remainingCount": 4, "remainingIds": [ "145604", "455665", "461663", "68182" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 }, { "probeId": "461663", "probe": "Khulsanurus", "remainingCount": 4, "remainingIds": [ "145604", "455665", "479065", "68182" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 }, { "probeId": "175493", "probe": "Linhenykus", "remainingCount": 5, "remainingIds": [ "145604", "455665", "461663", "479065", "68182" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 }, { "probeId": "53210", "probe": "Mononykus", "remainingCount": 5, "remainingIds": [ "145604", "455665", "461663", "479065", "68182" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 }, { "probeId": "68182", "probe": "Parvicursor", "remainingCount": 4, "remainingIds": [ "145604", "455665", "461663", "479065" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 }, { "probeId": "66043", "probe": "Shuvuuia", "remainingCount": 5, "remainingIds": [ "145604", "455665", "461663", "479065", "68182" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 }, { "probeId": "165127", "probe": "Xixianykus", "remainingCount": 5, "remainingIds": [ "145604", "455665", "461663", "479065", "68182" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 } ] }, { "target": "Parvicursor", "targetId": "68182", "anchor": "Baruungoyot Formation · MN", "beforeMin": 5, "beforeMax": 6, "afterMin": 4, "afterMax": 5, "comparison": { "knownMatches": [ "Ceratonykus", "Jaculinykus", "Khulsanurus", "Ondogurvel", "Parvicursor" ], "qualifiedOnlyMatches": [], "unknownMetadata": [], "provisionalNonMatches": [ "Albinykus", "Dzharaonyx", "Linhenykus", "Mononykus", "Shuvuuia", "Xixianykus" ], "retainedCount": 5, "occurrenceIdsByGenus": { "Ceratonykus": [ "809197" ], "Jaculinykus": [ "1639584" ], "Khulsanurus": [ "1604958" ], "Ondogurvel": [ "1593675" ], "Parvicursor": [ "283992" ] }, "literatureIdsByGenus": { "Ceratonykus": [ "asian-sauropod-1" ], "Jaculinykus": [ "asian-sauropod-1" ], "Khulsanurus": [ "asian-sauropod-1" ], "Ondogurvel": [ "asian-sauropod-1" ], "Parvicursor": [ "asian-sauropod-1" ] } }, "states": [ { "probeId": "177464", "probe": "Albinykus", "remainingCount": 5, "remainingIds": [ "145604", "455665", "461663", "479065", "68182" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 }, { "probeId": "145604", "probe": "Ceratonykus", "remainingCount": 4, "remainingIds": [ "455665", "461663", "479065", "68182" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 }, { "probeId": "473892", "probe": "Dzharaonyx", "remainingCount": 5, "remainingIds": [ "145604", "455665", "461663", "479065", "68182" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 }, { "probeId": "479065", "probe": "Jaculinykus", "remainingCount": 4, "remainingIds": [ "145604", "455665", "461663", "68182" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 }, { "probeId": "461663", "probe": "Khulsanurus", "remainingCount": 4, "remainingIds": [ "145604", "455665", "479065", "68182" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 }, { "probeId": "175493", "probe": "Linhenykus", "remainingCount": 5, "remainingIds": [ "145604", "455665", "461663", "479065", "68182" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 }, { "probeId": "53210", "probe": "Mononykus", "remainingCount": 5, "remainingIds": [ "145604", "455665", "461663", "479065", "68182" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 }, { "probeId": "455665", "probe": "Ondogurvel", "remainingCount": 4, "remainingIds": [ "145604", "461663", "479065", "68182" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 }, { "probeId": "66043", "probe": "Shuvuuia", "remainingCount": 5, "remainingIds": [ "145604", "455665", "461663", "479065", "68182" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 }, { "probeId": "165127", "probe": "Xixianykus", "remainingCount": 5, "remainingIds": [ "145604", "455665", "461663", "479065", "68182" ], "otherCandidatesRuledOut": 0 } ] } ], "references": [ { "label": "Chiappe, Norell & Clark 1998 · original description", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1038/32642", "finding": "The publisher identifies the described taxon as Shuvuuia deserti." }, { "label": "Suzuki et al. 2002 · systematic treatment", "url": "https://www.researchgate.net/publication/270218031_A_New_Specimen_of_Shuvuuia_Deserti_Chiappe_et_al_1998_from_the_Mongolian_Late_Cretaceous_with_a_Discussion_of_the_Relationship_of_Alvarezsaurids_to_Other_Theropod_Dinosaurs", "finding": "The systematic section uses Shuvuuia deserti Chiappe et al. 1998 and identifies holotype MGI 100/975, tying the name to the same described genus. Its locality statements concern listed specimens, not exhaustive absence from other formations." } ] }